Media That Reflects Old or New Ideals?

By Ryan Dettmann

In some of the readings this semester’s readings there has been mostly separation between the races and them rarely conversing. One example is Gone With The Wind, in which Mammy rarely is basically the only main black character in the movie and the rest are white, which reflects old ideas of the South. The subject we should investigate or look at is the media today and see if you can find certain shows or current media that portrays old southern ideals or values, or shows a counterexamples to presumed old southern values and/or instead injects breadth of different ones.

There are several modes of entertainment in which today are still in a sense like this, in which generally the characters are of one ethnicity except for one or two characters. Granted sometimes this is for humor in a way, it is seen in movies or shows such as This Christmas or Family Guy. In the first one the all the main characters are black except one who is at first considered an outcast based on her skin and then accepted to the family through her struggle and marriage to one of the men in the family. In Family Guy Most of the characters that appear are white except Cleveland, who they occasionally poke fun at him and actually made a spin off show on him and his new family.

Other shows have happened to have this similar trend such as Tyler Perry’s House of Pain, in which all the reoccurring characters are black except one of the firemen, who is kinda slow. But the show also addresses many stereotypes and situations that can be racist or have racial tensions that happened in the South and how they can affect many ethnicities. These and other shows address issues of old southern ideals or satirically portrays.

Many Places or Nonplaces

By Ryan Dettmann

Throughout my life I have lived in towns or cities that are described as a place on a nonplace. I was born in Chicago, Illinois which is by far a place. Its known for its deep dish pizza, sports teams, skyscrapers, and many other things that make the town memorable. But with this, it makes a crowded city that more crowded with the millions of tourists and visitors that visit the city. From Chicago’s hospital, I was taken to my families suburb of Barrington, Illinois which at the time was away from the city a somewhat of a nonplace with a small town atmosphere. But Since I left there it has become a place mainly, because it was engulfed by the city and has gotten significantly larger.

After living there I moved to the great cheese state of Wisconsin to a town named Middleton. It is the sister city of the capital Madison and is across lake Mindota. In most the sense Middleton was a place with big schools and places, with it literally being connected to Madison. Madison/Middleton was most known for being the capital of Wisconsin, its school University of Wisconsin, and cheese of course. It is also a place known for its liberal ideas and commonly in schools being clicky. Most recently the town was known from being picked a couple of years ago as the best place to live in the United States, which makes it that more a place.

After living there five years my family moved again and that next place was Charlottesville, Virginia. We actually live outside the city near the towns of Crozet and Ivy, but my address says Charlottesville. Charlottesville is a smaller town compared to Middleton of Barrington, but is widely known for rich history that attracts tourists from around the world. The most notably places are Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello and also University of Virginia, the school that Jefferson founded. It’s streets are flooded by tourists and college students every year, yet it fights to expand its boundaries like adding bypasses or allowing buildings to be taller than the Rotunda at UVa’s Lawn.The city is also known for being named the best place to live recently like Middleton. I did not go to school in Charlottesville, but rather I went to high school in Crozet, which is 20 minutes outside of the city. It is a quaint town, with three gas stations, a small library by the railroad tracks, and small town feel. It doesn’t have much going on unless its a school event, but everyone likes it that way because the big events are what Charlottesville are for. Though it keeps expanding rapidly I hope it will never become place and stay a none place.

The Diversity in Clarkston

I currently live in the perfect nonplace of Lilburn, Georgia. This city is the very representation of the suburban areas that are portrayed in movies or on TV, where there is a "perfect" community of people living in harmony. In your dreams, this is the place where you wanted to grow up in and where you want to raise your kids in. In essence, Lilburn is the place where you feel "normal"; however, for the last twelve years of my life, I always missed, for some reason I can't explain, living in a place like Clarkston.



When my parents first came to America from India, a relative suggested that they live Clarkston because it easily provided an area where my parents could start their new lives. From then on and continuing until I was six, my parents stayed in that city, took advantages of various opportunities, and lived happily. As a kid, though, I never like it there. The buildings were too old, the city was too congested, and the lifestyle was below average. Nevertheless, I got my wish and moved to a suburban area, but after a while, I realized that I never appreciated the city as it was.

You heard of Clarkston in one of our readings for class, an essay by Sally Jenkins, where it mentions that the city that houses one of the largest refugee resettlements in the nation. In the 1990s, refugee resettlement programs made Clarkston a home for displaced people of many different backgrounds. Several ethnics groups were also attracted to the city because of the city's location right outside of the core of Atlanta. According to the 2000 census, the racial makeup of the city is as follows:

• African Americans - 56%
• Caucasian - 19%
• Asian - 13%
• Hispanic/Latino - 4.61%
• Other races - 3%
• Two or more races - 10%

As seen by the numbers, Clarkston truly is a ethnic melting pot. In the 2000s, the local high school had students from more than 50 different countries. From these facts, you should probably be able to figure out why Clarkston is a place. I agree with Jenkins in that the city does foil the stereotype of the South, and in a way, it helps build a new Southern identity because the ethnic groups "have revitalized the region’s business and spiritual life" (Jenkins).

Music City, Cashville, Nashville

I was born in San Francisco but I consider Nashville to be where I'm from. I moved to Memphis when I was 1 and to Nashville when I was 4, so Nashville is the only place I really remember. Nashville is a place without a doubt, according to Walker Percy. Just about everyone knows of Nashville because of all the country music that is recorded there. It is home to the Grand Ole Opry, Country Music Hall of Fame, and the only full-scale replica of the Parthenon. There are many famous people that live in Nashville and you see them around the city all the time. For how well it's known, Nashville isn't that big. There are only about 1.5 million in the city and surrounding area. Nashville has a lot to offer, especially music-wise, and is not too crowded. Nashville is home to the Titans (football) and the Predators (Hockey), so there is a fairly decent sport scene as well. Nashville is sometimes called Music City (obviously for all the music there) or Cashville (for Johnny Cash). Also, Nashville hosts the Country Music Association Awards (CMA Awards).

Contrast

I have experienced both, living in a place and in a nonplace. I was born in Colombia in a tiny, but very recognized city called Barranquilla. I lived there for the first 12 years of my life. Barranquilla is in the coastal part of Colombia and is known by its famous Carnival, which everybody should attend once in their lifetime. It is a huge celebration, even causing schools and important government issues to come to a halt. As in America, Colombia is divided into stereotypes. The people from the Coastal area labeled as joyful, partiers, and kind of lazy. The coast is recognized for being home to the most beautiful beaches and cultural cities of Colombia, such as Cartagena. The other stereotype that exists is for the people from the interior of Colombia. They are portrayed as serious, educated, and boring. I consider Barranquilla a place, because as Walker Percy's essay "Why I live and Where I live" pointed out, people from Barranquilla carry in their shoulders all the traditions and history that the city and its surroundings have embedded in them. After 12 years, when I moved to the United States, I lived in a new, small city called Weston. Weston is located in South Florida, 40 minutes from Miami, which I consider a place, and was established in 1996, 14 years ago. When I first went to Weston, I realized it looked like paradise. It is full of big green palms and trees, the streets were broad and royal, and it had an empty atmosphere. I consider Weston a nonplace because although it had a resemblance of being perfect, it seemed fake. Something that characterizes Weston is how nothing interesting occurs. There is no news, no crime, and by 10 p.m. the streets are empty. Don't get me wrong though, in both cities I have had pleasant experiences and I am emotionally attached to both, but I would consider Barranquilla the place that contributed to my cultural preferences and makes me in many ways how I am. This is why, if anybody asks me if I was characterized by the place I was born/raised in, under no hesitation would I respond, "Yes."

The picture at the top is of Weston and the picture at the bottom is of the 'marimondas' from the Carnival of Barranquilla.

Topic #1

Hello! This is Hye Jin. So I'm the first one to introduce the topic. Because it is the first topic and we don't know each other very well, I was thinking what topic would relate to our class discussion and somehow introduce ourselves.

After reading Walker Percy's essay "Why I live and Where I live", I have thought about my life and said that I have mostly lived in a place and once in nonplace, based on Percy's definition of place and nonplace.

I was born in Seoul, South Korea but lived there for about 7 years total. I have lived in Chennai, India for 8 years and 3 years in Irvine, CA. I was also in Kiev, Ukraine last summer because my parents lived there at that time. In my opinion, Seoul, Chennai and Kiev is a place. These cities are huge and are full of history of the country. The modern building and the historical buildings in major parts of the city blend with each other very well.

(left is Seoul, center is Chennai, and right is Kiev)

However, Irvine, in my opinion is a nonplace. Irvine is a suburb that does not have unique and historical architects. It is a city that clearly differentiate residential area and shopping area. Automobile is required to go some where. The main reason why Irvine is known to people is because of its academics. Although my father's workplace was 30 minutes drive from Irvine, my father wanted our family to live in Irvine because of my high school academics. Due to the high reputation of academics, a lot of Asians currently live in Irvine. About 50 % of my high school students were Asians. Because of the increase in population and more malls coming in to the city, it might be considered as a place. Nevertheless, most suburban people tend to live on their own inside their houses, according to my observation. There was no interaction between neighbors.

Yeah, so that's how I defined the cities I lived to place and nonplace. So the topic for this week is to introduce where you have lived throughout your life and discuss if it was a place or a nonplace.

The Stereotypical Southern

By Ryan Dettmann

When people think of the stereotypical southern identity, many think of several things such as football, pickup trucks, hunting, alcohol, and possible a good ole southern draw. Before we had even gotten this assignment there were several ideas and stereotypes that came to mind about views on southern culture which included the ones mentioned before. So when we got the assignment I found a youtube video that further skews people's views on the people of the south.

This is a video about a man who bet his tv on the Washington Redskins winning against the New Orleans Saints and sadly lost. Now his friends are cashing in on that bet. He explains also in the video what they might do and show what they actually do, which is shoot up his tv while having some beers by their pickups and big southern accents. This video offers a stereotypical view of the south as a bunch drunk guys or hillbillies shooting up a tv over a football game. This is not what I view most the south as but it does show strengthen people's stereotypes that its a bunch of unintelligent drunk people who are not very smart have nothing better to do than shoot up a tv and this is shown in the video.

Though many people could view this video as a representation of the south, for me it does not accurately portray the it. Not everybody shoots up their friends tv, or drink beer and shoot up things, or even have pick-up trucks (though many Americans do). Though I do believe that many people live by football or other sports, this is true all over the world like europe with soccer. Although this video wrongly portrays southerners as a bunch of drunk stupid rednecks, some underlying things are popular in the South like football.